Flavius Josephus (37-100 AD) was Jewish historian whose voluminous writings provide crucial insight into what modern historians refer to as “late 2nd temple Judaism.” Israel’s first temple was completed by King Solomon around 960 BC. This magnificent edifice stood for almost four centuries before being destroyed by the Babylonians in 586 BC. After the exile, a remnant of Jews returned to Jerusalem and rebuilt the temple in 516 BC, thus marking the beginning of the second temple period. In 20 BC, King Herod the Great began refurbishing the temple and greatly expanded the temple mount. The second temple period concluded when the Roman legions under Titus razed the temple in 70 AD. Late second temple Judaism was the world inhabited by Jesus and the early Christians.

It’s not uncommon to encounter skeptics who claim that Jesus of Nazareth is a mythic figure and that the New Testament is a work of fiction. But no reputable historian doubts that Jesus was a real person. In the last blog, we examined Josephus’ 90-word description of Jesus in his work Antiquities of the Jews, composed around 94 AD. This passage has garnered so much attention that it has acquired a title of its own: the Testimonium Flavianum. Most historians believe that the Testimonium was significantly embellished by Christian scribes. But even the non-disputed portions confirm that Jesus was regarded as a “wise man” who performed “remarkable deeds” and was condemned to death on the cross by Pontius Pilate. And recent scholarship (including modern linguistic analysis) suggests that the Testimonium may be entirely, or almost entirely genuine.
Josephus also makes a second reference to Jesus in Antiquities. This later passage describes the execution of James, the brother of Jesus, at the hands of the high priest Ananus: “But the younger Ananus who, as we said, received the high priesthood, was of a bold disposition and exceptionally daring; he followed the party of the Sadducees, who are severe in judgment above all the Jews, as we have already shown. As therefore Ananus was of such a disposition, he thought he had now a good opportunity, as Festus was now dead, and Albinus was still on the road; so he assembled a council of judges, and brought before it the brother of Jesus the so-called Christ, whose name was James, together with some others, and having accused them as lawbreakers, he delivered them over to be stoned.”
The vast majority of historians consider this passage to be entirely authentic. These events transpired in 62 AD, just after the death of the Roman procurator Porcius Festus. The emperor (Nero) appointed a man named Albinus to replace the deceased Festus. But while Albinus was in route to Judea, the high priest Ananus took advantage of this transition to dispatch some men whom he regarded as troublemakers, including James the brother of Jesus.

Like the Testimonium Flavianum, this passage provides a wealth of historical information. Most importantly, it gives us another reference to Jesus of Nazareth and confirms that his earliest followers regarded him as “the Christ” – Gods’ anointed king. Josephus bears witness that the Christian belief in Jesus as the Messiah is rooted deep in the 1st century. It’s not (as some skeptics say) a legend which developed much later.
Josephus also confirms that Jesus had a brother named James, whom the High Priest Ananus obviously regarded as a threat to be eliminated.
The gospel of Matthew mentions James as one of Jesus’ brothers. (Matthew 13:55) But John’s gospel tells us that during his public ministry Jesus’ brothers “did not believe in him.” (John 7:5) This is a remarkable admission and a strong indication that John was committed to telling the whole truth rather than suppressing information which would have been potentially embarrassing to the early church.
In Paul’s letter to the Corinthians, we learn that the risen Jesus appeared to James. (I Corinthians 15:7) Thereafter, James became a leading figure in the church in Jerusalem. We see James exercise his leadership (along with Peter & Paul) at the church council in Jerusalem described in Acts 15. Some have surmised that James essentially presided over this council, since he was the last to speak and his recommendations were adopted. The apostle Paul wrote that James, Peter & John were esteemed as “pillars” in the church. (Galatians 2:9)

A 2nd century Christian named Hegesippus tells us about James’ later life. (Most of Hegesippus’ writings have been lost. But thankfully the 4th century historian Eusebius quotes him.) Hegesippus tells us that James became the first bishop of the church in Jerusalem. Because of his virtuous life, he was known as James “the Just.” It was said that he kneeled so often in prayer “that his knees became hard like those of a camel.”
Hegesippus gives us a dramatic (perhaps somewhat embellished) account of James’ martyrdom. According to this story, the Jewish leaders took James to the summit of the temple and demanded that he denounce Jesus as an imposter before the crowds. But James remained loyal until the very end. In a scene reminiscent of Jesus’ own trial before Caiaphas, James loudly proclaimed that Jesus was indeed the Messianic figure prophesied by Daniel: “Why do you ask me about Jesus the Son of Man? He himself sits in heaven, at the right hand of the Great Power, and shall come on the clouds of heaven.” Enraged by this response, the Jews cast James down from the temple precipice. When he managed to survive the fall, they began stoning him. Even then, poor James didn’t die until he was struck over the head with a fuller’s staff.

Everything that the scriptures tell us about James accords well with Josephus. The book of Acts describes constant conflict between the Jewish hierarchy and the followers of Jesus. Acts 6 & 7 records how the first Christian martyr Stephen was dragged before the high priest & the Sanhedrin and stoned to death.
We also learn about the death of James, the son of Zebedee and one of Jesus’ twelve apostles: “It was about this time that King Herod arrested some who belonged to the church, intending to persecute them. He had James, the brother of John, put to death with the sword.” (Acts 12:1-2) This transpired in 44 AD during the reign of Herod Agrippa I (Herod the Great’s grandson). Peter narrowly avoided the same grisly fate when an angel miraculously freed him from prison. (Acts 12:3-11)
It makes perfect historical sense that the high priest Ananus would seek to eliminate James, the acknowledged leader of this troublesome sect. Josephus tells us that Ananus had a very short tenure of less than 3 months as high priest. He was quickly deposed because his illegal & unjust execution of James greatly upset many Judean citizens and angered the new Roman procurator Albinus, who had sole authority to apply the death penalty.
The biblical account of Jesus’ trial confirms that only the Roman governor (the “prefect” or “procurator”) could impose capital punishment. When Jesus was brought before Pilate, the governor initially attempted to avoid the situation, telling the Jews: “Take him yourselves and judge him by your own law.” But the Jews responded, “But we have no right to execute anyone.” (John 18:31)

The Ananus who executed James “the Just” was variously known as Ananus II, Annas II or Ananus the Younger. Fascinatingly, a generation earlier, his father Annas played a role in the trial of Jesus. “Then the detachment of soldiers with its commander and the Jewish officials arrested Jesus. They bound him and brought him first to Annas, who the father-in-law of Caiaphas, the high priest that year.” (John 18:12-13) Jesus’ interrogation before Annas (John 18:19-23) seems to have been a sort of preliminary hearing prior to the main trial before Caiaphas.
Annas was later called Annas I, Ananus I or Ananus the Elder to distinguish him from his son. He officially held the high priesthood from 6-15 AD, but remained highly influential for decades to come, in no small part because five of his sons and one son-in-law held the high priestly office after him. His son-in-law Caiaphas had an unusually long tenure as high priest (18-36 AD), thus overlapping the ministry of Jesus. Of course, Caiaphas is frequently mentioned in the gospels.
Josephus confirms that the party of the Sadducees controlled the office of high priest, just as the Bible claims. Even in regard to the preferred method of execution Josephus agrees with the scriptures: the Romans crucified criminals (unless they were Roman citizens in which case they were beheaded) while the Jews stoned offenders.
As we’ve noted, Flavius Josephus was not a Christian. But his account of James’ martyrdom is a key piece of evidence which in many respects confirms the historical reliability of the scriptures.